top of page

How and When to Say Goodbye to Your Child's Pacifier

Pacifiers, also known as binkies or soothers, are used to provide comfort to babies through the act of sucking. While they offer benefits like reducing the risk of SIDS and helping preemies in the NICU, long-term pacifier use can increase the risk of dental malocclusion (misalignment of teeth).

The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP), American Academy of Family Physicians (AAFP), and American Academy of Pediatric Dentistry (AAPD) recommend weaning pacifiers around 18 months when canines emerge, actively discouraging use before 3 years old to avoid potential side effects of taking pacifier away like dental issues. Some parents may choose to keep the pacifier until 1 year per SIDS prevention guidelines, while others wean earlier if problems arise. So, how and when to wean from a pacifier?

how and when to wean from a pacifier

Understanding Your Child's Pacifier Dependence

Around 2.5 years old, children develop a better sense of awareness and can better understand the transition away from the pacifier. Weaning before 3 years old may impact naps if the child has a strong pacifier sleep association.

Pacifiers can provide soothing and comfort for some babies, helping them fall asleep or calm down between feedings. The sucking reflex is strong in many babies, and pacifiers can satisfy this need. They may also temporarily distract and soothe babies during procedures like shots or blood tests.

However, prolonged pacifier use past age 2-4 can lead to dental problems and misalignment of teeth. It may also disrupt breastfeeding if introduced before 3-4 weeks when nursing is well-established. Continuing to use a pacifier can hinder a child's ability to express their needs and talk.

How and When to Wean from a pacifier?

The optimal time to wean a child off the pacifier is around 12-18 months of age, when the canine teeth begin to emerge. At this stage, prolonged pacifier use can lead to dental issues and misalignment of teeth.

  • The easiest time to wean a baby off a pacifier is around 6-7 months of age, before they develop a strong emotional attachment to it. After 9 months, children tend to form a stronger attachment, making the weaning process more challenging.

  • Around 18 months, it's advisable to start reducing pacifier access to only nighttime or stressful situations before completely taking it away. Most children are emotionally ready to wean off the pacifier on their own by 2-4 years old.

  • The American Academy of Pediatric Dentistry (AAPD) recommends weaning from the pacifier by age 3 to reduce the risk of dental malocclusions (misalignment of teeth).

It's crucial to consider your child's individual needs and readiness when timing the transition away from the pacifier. While some children may be ready to wean off earlier, others may require a more gradual approach.

Preparing for the Change

Preparing for the transition away from the pacifier requires a thoughtful and gradual approach. Here are some tips to consider:

  • Consistency is Key: Ensure all caregivers (parents, grandparents, daycare providers) are on the same page and follow the weaning plan consistently. Inconsistency can confuse the child and prolong the process.

  • Stay Calm and Patient: Weaning can be challenging for both the child and parents. Maintain a calm and patient demeanor throughout the process, as children can sense frustration and may become more resistant.

  • Offer Alternative Comfort Objects: Introduce a special stuffed animal, blanket, or toy that can serve as a replacement for the pacifier. Allow the child to choose and bond with this new comfort object.

  • Use Positive Reinforcement: Praise and reward the child for their progress, rather than shaming or punishing them for seeking the pacifier. This encourages the desired behavior and makes the experience more positive.

  • Timing is Important: Avoid initiating the weaning process during times of stress or significant changes for the child, such as starting a new school or recovering from an illness. Choose a relatively stable period to minimize additional challenges.

  • Engage in Distractions: Keep the child's hands and mind occupied with toys, crafts, or activities to prevent them from reaching for the pacifier out of habit or boredom.

  • Explore Soothing Alternatives: Introduce alternative soothing methods, such as rocking, singing, or reading, to help the child self-soothe without relying on the pacifier.

  • Consider Traditions: Some families find success with the "Binky Fairy" tradition, where the child leaves their pacifier for the fairy, who then leaves a special treat or gift in exchange.

Remember, every child is unique, and the weaning process may require patience and adjustments. Celebrate small victories and remain consistent in your approach.

Weaning Strategies

There are several effective strategies to help wean a child off their pacifier. The approach can vary based on the child's age and attachment level:

Gradual Weaning: Start by limiting pacifier use to specific times like naps and bedtime. Progressively reduce access until it's no longer needed. This gentle approach works well for older toddlers.

  • Cold Turkey: For children under 12 months, going "cold turkey" and removing the pacifier completely can be effective, as their emotional attachment is typically lower. Provide alternative comfort objects like a stuffed animal or blanket.

  • Transitional Object: Introduce a new comfort item like a special stuffed toy or blanket to help replace the pacifier. Allow the child to bond with this "lovey" before removing the pacifier.

  • Positive Reinforcement: Praise and reward the child when they self-soothe without the pacifier. This encourages the desired behavior and makes the process more positive.

  • Special Traditions: Some families find success with the "Binky Fairy" tradition, where the child leaves their pacifier for the fairy, who then leaves a special gift in exchange. Others have a "Goodbye, Pacifier!" party to celebrate the transition.

Whichever strategy you choose, consistency from all caregivers and patience are key. The weaning process may take several days or weeks as the child adjusts to new sleep habits and self-soothing techniques. Offering alternative comfort objects and positive reinforcement can help make the transition smoother.

Weaning a child off the pacifier can be a challenging process, but with patience and consistency, it can be achieved successfully. Here are some tips to manage the challenges:

  • Expect Some Tears and Tantrums: It's normal for children to become upset or frustrated when their pacifier is taken away. Remain calm and offer alternative comfort objects or soothing techniques. The tantrums will eventually subside as the child adjusts to the new routine.

  • Stick to the Plan: Consistency is key. All caregivers should follow the weaning plan consistently to avoid confusing the child. If you give in and offer the pacifier during a difficult moment, it can prolong the process and undermine your efforts.

  • Nap and Bedtime Struggles: Nap times and bedtimes can be particularly challenging, as many children rely on the pacifier for self-soothing and sleep. Consider introducing a new bedtime routine with alternative comfort items, such as a special stuffed animal or blanket. You may need to provide extra cuddles and reassurance during this transition.

  • Seek Professional Guidance: If you're facing significant challenges or your child is experiencing excessive distress, don't hesitate to consult with your pediatric dentist or pediatrician. They can provide personalized guidance and recommendations based on your child's specific needs and circumstances.

Remember, the weaning process can take time, and every child is different. Be patient, stay consistent, and celebrate small victories along the way. With a gentle and supportive approach, your child will eventually adjust to life without the pacifier.


Saying goodbye to your child's pacifier can be an emotional journey, but it's an important step in their development. The process requires patience, consistency, and a gentle approach. By understanding your child's needs, timing the transition appropriately, and employing effective weaning strategies, you can successfully navigate this milestone.

Remember, every child is unique, and the journey may present challenges. However, with positive reinforcement, alternative comfort objects, and a supportive environment, your little one will learn to self-soothe without relying on the pacifier. If you're looking for professional guidance on your child's oral health, including pacifier usage, consider Hello Kids Dentistry in Bothell, WA, where experienced pediatric dentists are dedicated to addressing children's dental needs. Follow them on Facebook and Instagram or call 425-659-1200 to schedule an appointment.


What is the recommended age to stop using a pacifier?The American Academy of Pediatrics advises eliminating pacifier use between 2 and 4 years of age, while the American Academy of Pediatric Dentists suggests weaning off the pacifier by age 3. Generally, the ideal time for most toddlers to start weaning off the pacifier is between 2 and 3 years old.

How can I help my child let go of their pacifier?To help your child part with their pacifier, consider these strategies:

  • Gradually decrease the time your child spends with the pacifier to make the transition smoother.

  • Get creative with ways for your child to say farewell to their pacifier.

  • Read books together that address the topic of giving up the pacifier.

  • Introduce a different form of comfort, such as a stuffed animal or blanket.

  • Encourage your child to give their pacifier away, perhaps to a "baby who needs it."

  • If necessary, simply remove the pacifier without prior buildup.

At what point should I start weaning my baby off the pacifier?Although each child is unique and some may naturally stop using a pacifier without parental intervention, experts often recommend beginning the weaning process when your child is around 12-18 months old if they do not show signs of stopping on their own.

When is it important to stop pacifier use for the sake of my child's speech development?Speech-language pathologists commonly suggest that pacifier use should be discontinued around the age of 1 to avoid potential impacts on speech development.

24 views0 comments


bottom of page